Financial Reform Watch

Published — July 16, 2010 Updated — May 19, 2014 at 12:19 pm ET

Auto dealers should be happy


One of the biggest winners in the new financial services overhaul bill are the nation’s auto dealerships, which are now exempt from oversight by the federal Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Just as questionable practices by subprime lenders gave the mortgage industry a bad name — and contributed to the financial meltdown — there is a growing record of abuse in the auto financing industry. According to court records examined by the Center, the push to pump up profits includes tactics such as:

  • Unapproved charges and fees slipped into loan documents;
  • Interest rates jacked up to 17 percent or higher without customer knowledge;
  • Income amounts doubled or tripled so customer qualifies for unaffordable loans; and
  • Signatures forged on financing paperwork.

For most consumers, auto loans are their first or second-largest financial obligation. And auto lenders are not mom-and-pop shops but increasingly Wall-Street traded megadealer chains. Last year, AutoNation Inc. sold some 7 million vehicles and had revenues of $10.7 billion. Penske Automotive had $9 billion in revenue, and CarMax $7 billion. And, much like subprime lending, auto loans are repackaged and securitized on Wall Street. But despite the on-the-ground realities of auto financing, Congress gave the industry a pass. Car dealer associations spent some $3.5 million lobbying Congress on financial regulation and other issues, and the auto loan carve-out from federal oversight will be worth far more than the cost of lobbying.

This article originally appeared in The New York Times‘ “Room for Debate.”

Read more in Inequality, Opportunity and Poverty

Share this article

Join the conversation

Show Comments

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments